Abstract

Human traffickers continually develop new tactics to trick and trap their victims, making human trafficking a complex and evolving crime that demands a robust criminal justice response. This response must be consistently refined to combat this pervasive crime effectively. In South Africa, the Prevention and Combating of Trafficking in Persons Act 7 of 2013 (Trafficking Act) came into force in 2015 to address the multifaceted crime. Now, after eight years, this article delves into the status of the counter-trafficking response, focusing on the efficacy of the anti-trafficking legislation and its implementation by the courts. It was found that, first, the Trafficking Act, as previously confirmed, complies with international minimum standards, and encompasses all forms of trafficking. Secondly, through the implementation and interpretation of this legislation, the courts have established jurisprudence on human trafficking, making a significant contribution to the criminal justice response. By reviewing case law spanning the period 2009 to 2023, this article aims to contribute novel insights to the existing body of knowledge, based on evidence tested in courts. Examining emerging case law, the article sheds light on various features of human trafficking within the criminal justice arena. It focuses specifically on the gravity and nature of human trafficking, penalties imposed by the courts, both domestic and cross-border trafficking, and new insights into various types of trafficking perpetrated within South Africa. Notably, court judgments increasingly offer binding and clarifying decisions. Case law has endorsed the only legally binding definition of human trafficking and provided interpretations of concepts in trafficking legislation. However, alongside the positive contributions of case law, the article also identifies legislative challenges. Consequently, recommendations are presented to enhance and fortify the criminal justice response to human trafficking in South Africa.